This is a sort-of re-post of some comments that I've made elsewhere about "unanswered prayer" in relation to Pete Greig's book
God on Mute: Engaging the Silence of Unanswered Prayer. This is an extremely important topic that has wider repercussions in terms of our relationship with God, the nature of faith, and the nature, rules and practical outworking of the Kingdom of God.
According to
Scot McKnight, the book list 16 reasons for unanswered prayer, that is when the answer was not the one you were looking for! I'll list them here without comment. At the end (
and please read down, as the point of the post is here!), I present a
17th reason. Let me know what you think
Pete Greig's 16 reasons for unanswered prayer (as told by Scot McKnight):
1. Common sense: Am I asking God to do something stupid, meaningless, or illogical?
2. Contradiction: Are my prayers likely to be conflicting with those of someone else?
3. Laws of nature: Are my prayers potentially detrimental to the natural order or to the lives of others?
4. Life is tough: Am I expecting God to spare me from stuff that’s just common human experience because of the Fall?
5. Doctrine: Does my prayer reflect God’s character and His promises in the Bible? Might it be out of line with his His will for my life?
6. Second best: Although my desire in prayer is for something good, is it possible that God has something even better in store for me?
7. Motive: Are my prayers essentially just selfish?
8. Relationship: Is there an opportunity here for going deeper in my relationship with God?
9. Free will: Am I expecting God to override someone’s free will?
10. Influence: Am I trying to exercise ungodly power over a person’s life in prayer?
11. Satanic opposition: Is my prayer in line with God’s will but experiencing specific demonic resistance?
12. Faith: Do I really believe that God can do this? Am I out of my league?
13. Perseverance: Do I want it enough to keep praying?
14. Sin: Honesty time: Is there some secret sin you need to confess?
15. Justice: Am I actively seeking to express God’s love for the poor?
16. None of the first 15: Am I trying to find answers where I need instead to trust?
While there is merit in many of these 16 reasons, I think that there is one further reason that, although it could be classified under #5 (Doctrine), is
sooo important that it needs to explicitly teased out. Here it is:
Reason 17. Entirely wrong view of God.It is hard to pray with the faith that will really move a mountain when you are crippled with the entirely wrong view of God. So many of us are angry with God for letting such and such happen. Why me? Why my son?
Many people that I minister to are, when you dig a little, actually angry with God for a) doing the bad deed, or b) not doing the good deed. In the end we cannot have real faith if we deny the true nature of God - regardless of what we think, do and experience,
God is Good. Jesus said it. Do you really believe it? Even Job had the wrong view of God - he believed that God was secretly waiting to bash him the moment he set a foot out of line (Job 10v13-14). How sick is that? In John 10, Jesus explains to us who comes to kill, steal and destroy and he points out that he is the good shepherd.
When we are in agreement with God’s will (and we are when we are praying for healing) we should expect an “answer” to prayer. However, God’s will isn’t always done on earth. That’s why Jesus told us to pray that it would be done here!
God is good.
The problem is at our end.
Let's recognise that first and foremost.